|
How
does the US Dollar Defy the Law of Gravity?
by
Gary Dorsch, Editor, Global Money Trends
Trading
in foreign exchange is akin to judging a reverse beauty contest. The
trick is to buy the “least ugly” currency at the right time.
Nearly every central bank is engaging in some sort of manipulation of
its currency, from outright intervention in the marketplace, such as
in Brazil and China, to pumping up the money supply to inflate local
stock markets, such as in Australia, China, England, the Euro zone,
and India. Other central banks engage in “verbal jawboning” to
keep traders in check.
Central
banks are key players in the $2 trillion-a-day currency market, and
traders are always on the lookout for signals that central banks are
diversifying their FX reserves away from the US dollar. Global central
bank reserves have more than doubled to $4.9 trillion in just three
years, with particular focus on the massive US dollar stockpiles built
up by Asian central banks, which could be switched into other
currencies such as the Euro, Japanese yen, British pound, or Gold.
The
US dollar accounted for 66% of foreign currency reserves held by
global central banks in 2005, with 25% stashed in the Euro, 5% in the
British pound, and 4% in the Japanese yen. In
London
, the world’s largest FX market, the Euro accounts for 35% of its
average daily trading volume of $942 billion.
Traders often look to the Euro,
yen, and pound to gauge the mood of the global currency markets.

For
the past six months, the Euro, Japanese yen, and British pound have
been remarkably stable against the US dollar, locked into a 4% to 5%
trading ranges. So the big question is: How did the big-4 central
banks and their finance officials pull off such remarkable currency
stability, at a time of enormous global trade imbalances, and 10% to
25% swings in global commodity and stock markets?
Recent
history in the Euro, Yen and Sterling
The
Euro’s last major move in late-April thru mid-May, and extended from
$1.21 to a high of $1.30, before coming to an abrupt end, when top
European finance ministers objected to further gains above $1.30. On
May 16th, French Finance Minister Thierry Breton, said the
French economy could tolerate the Euro’s rally to $1.30, but, "We
must be very attentive to exchange rates. We will do everything so
that this difference between the Euro and US dollar doesn’t keep
growing.”
Breton
was backed-up by verbal jawboning from Bank of
France
chief Christian Noyer on May 16th. "Big
movements in the foreign exchange market could hamper economic growth
in the Euro area, and run exactly contrary to G-7 efforts to rebalance
the global economy. So certainly, this is not something that is
warranted. The clear consensus in the G-7, is that there should not be
any correction between the dollar and especially the Euro and other
European currencies,” Noyer warned.
Then
on May 21st, German Deputy
Finance Minister Thomas Mirow added, "We don’t see problems
from a rising Euro for us because of the nature of our exports,”
driven by technology companies competing in high-end, high quality
markets. “Still, we do not want to see abrupt changes of exchange
rates. So at the Euro level of $1.27-$1.30 we esteem that there are no
acute problems for
Germany
,” he added.

As
if by magic, the Euro obeyed the whims of the Group of Seven,
stabilizing within a tight range between $1.25 and $1.30. The Euro did
attempt a break-out rally towards $1.30, after the Federal Reserve
paused in its 2-year rate hike campaign at 5.25% on August 8th.
With the Fed on the sidelines, the European Central Bank lifted its
repo rate twice to 3.25%, and telegraphed a third hike to 3.50% in
December, which in theory, should make the
Euro more attractive.
Instead,
the Euro did a U-turn, tumbling from a high of $1.2939 on August 21st
to as low as $1.2480 on October 13th. The reason for the
Euro’s slide didn’t become apparent until October 17th,
when the US Treasury said foreign demand for US bonds and stocks had
soared to $116.8 billion in August from $32.9 billion in July, far
higher than the monthly
US
trade deficit of $69.9 billion.

Against
the Japanese yen, the US dollar bottomed out at 114-yen on August 8th,
within minutes of the Fed’s announcement of a pause in its rate hike
campaign. The
US
$ climbed 5-yen in a see-saw pattern to as high as 119.88-yen on
October 13th. Japanese investors were net buyers of $7.6
billion of US Treasuries in August, their largest purchase in
14-months, anxious to lock in 5% yields on
US
long bonds.
But
the dollar received its biggest boost against the yen from
Tokyo
’s sleight of hand on August 25th, when Japanese
apparatchniks re-jigged the consumer price index, and revised the
inflation rate lower by two-thirds from the previous calculation. That
handcuffed the Bank of Japan (BoJ), and ignited a rally in Japanese
yen Libor futures to 99.50 from 99.34, which effectively ruled out a
BOJ rate hike in Q’4.
The
US dollar hit resistance at the psychological 120-yen level on Oct 13th,
when BoJ chief Toshiro Fukui hinted at a rate hike, despite
Tokyo
’s re-jig of the inflation data. “If you ask me whether there’s
a possibility of another rise in interest rates within this year, I
cannot deny that possibility,” he warned. Then on October 16th,
Russia
’s central bank said it planned to convert some of its $267 billion
of foreign currency reserves into Japanese yen, triggering dollar
sales below120-yen.
Russia
’s finance chief Alexei
Kudrin ignited a big rally for the volatile British pound in late
April, when he questioned the
US
$’s status as the world’s reserve currency. Speculators jolted the
British pound from $1.74 to the $1.90 psychological level on May 14th,
where the currency has been capped for the past six months. The Bank
of Italy announced on August 3rd, that it had boosted
sterling to 25% of its $79 billion in FX reserves, briefly lifting the
pound to $1.91, where it ran into a brick wall.
The
British pound is a favorite among currency speculators, because of the
Bank of England’s “hands-off” policy. Last week, the
BoE received the green light to hike its base rate by 0.25% to 5.00%
on November 9th. UK Treasury minister Edward Balls signaled
on October 20th. “With the economy growing more strongly than
expected and with upward pressure on global commodity prices we must
all remain vigilant. We need continued discipline in wage-setting and
pay-bargaining across the private and public sectors,” he said.
How
the US$ defies the Law of Gravity
The
giant
US
trade deficit has generated a huge outflow of dollars, and
behind-the-scenes strategies to bring the money back home. For
the first eight months of 2006, the
US
trade deficit rose to $522.9 billion, and is likely to exceed the 2005
shortfall of $726 billion. Such a sea of red ink suggests the US
dollar is still overvalued on a trade weighted and prone to a further
devaluation.
Nearly
a third of the
US
trade deficit in August was with
China
, widening to a record $22 billion, and twice the $11-billion deficit
posted with the European Union, and three times the $7.5-billion US
deficit with
Japan
. By
the end of September,
China
’s global trade surplus was at $110.9-billion this year, surpassing
the annual record of $102-billion set in 2005,
and on course to reach $150 billion in 2006.
China’s
trade surpluses with the European Union of $127 billion and with the
US of $202 billion in 2005, enabled it to become the world’s third
largest trading nation, exporting and importing about $1.4 trillion
worth of goods and services a year.
Robust
exports and bank loan growth of 15.2% have defied planners’ efforts
to rein in economic growth, projected at 10.5% for this year.

Under
the Bush administration, the
US
trade deficit has mushroomed from about $26 billion per month in 2002,
to as high as $70 billion in August 2006. The US dollar’s 30%
devaluation against a basket of currencies since 2002, including the
Euro, British pound, Canadian dollar, and Japanese yen, did catapult
US exports to a record high of $122.4 billion in August ‘06, but
import growth was still stronger at $192.3 billion, and generating
record US trade deficits.
The
US
trade deficit remains stubbornly high, partly because the undervalued
Chinese yuan pushes up imports of Chinese goods and handicaps
US
exporters of durable goods and high-end services. Also, record high
oil prices boosted
US
oil imports to $27.2 billion in August, and the world’s biggest
economy was on course for a whopping $320 billion oil bill this year,
until the latest plunge in oil prices.

Financing
the
US
external deficit requires increasing agility. Every business day
requires $3.5 billion of net new money to enter the
US
markets, to prevent the US dollar from falling under its own weight.
Most of that money comes from Asian central banks and Arab oil
producers, which own large amounts of dollars.
Japan
is the largest holder of $644.2 billion
of US Treasuries, and
China
is the second-largest holder with $339 billion.
London
based brokers added $11.1 billion of US Treasuries to their clients’
portfolios in August, including members of OPEC, to a record $210.4
billion. Overall, foreigners now own $2.14 trillion, or 46% of the
$4.5 trillion of marketable US Treasuries.
The
US Treasury’s Secret agreement with
Beijing
The
Bush administration’s dealings with
Beijing
are simple, free Chinese access to US consumer markets, and acceptance
of the undervalued yuan, in return for massive Chinese purchases of US
bonds.
China
is loath to increase the yuan enough to dampen growth in its coastal
factories. Exports are a key source of jobs in a country that must
employ tens of millions of poor farmers and workers laid off by
bankrupt state factories, in the continued transition from communism
to capitalism
The
Chinese central bank prints yuan in exchange for the foreign currency
flowing into the country, and in the process, has increased its M2
money supply by 18% for the past few years.
Beijing
added
$169-billion to its foreign currency reserves in the first nine months
of this year, which will soon top
$1 trillion, the world’s largest.
Beijing
’s satellite, the Hong Kong Monetary Authority said its foreign
currency reserve assets rose $1.4 billion to $130.3 billion in
September.
China
purchased more than $200 billion in US
and other foreign debt last year, equal to 9% of its economic output
and about 25% of its exports.
China
has recycled about 70% of its $988 billion foreign
currency reserves into US Treasury and other government agency debt,
helping to keep US
mortgage rates artificially low. In return, the Bush administration
killed the Schumer-Graham bill that would have slapped a 27.5% tariff
on Chinese imports into the
US
.
Beijing
has limited the yuan’s gains to 2.1%
since it ended the rigid dollar peg in July 2005, and is expected to
limit the dollar’s decline to 3% this year, to minimize losses to
its massive
US
bond portfolio. Yu Yongding, an adviser to the central bank has
warned, “
China
’s economy would take a big hit if the US dollar weakened sharply
due to such factors as a bursting of the
US
property bubble. The loss for
China
’s foreign exchange reserves would be extremely serious.”

Subsidizing
its exports with an undervalued yuan has allowed
China
’s cargo trade to reach about 56% of the level of the
United States
and 82% of
Germany
’s. But
Beijing
is paying a heavy price in its trade dealings with the Bush
administration. The purchasing power of US Treasury notes in relation
to gold has dropped in half from four years ago, making it much more
expensive for
Beijing
to switch its reserves from
US
debt to gold.
Beijing
holds only 1.5% of its FX reserves in gold.
And
the million dollar question in the foreign exchange and gold markets
is how will
Beijing
manage its bloating reserves in the years ahead?
China
’s FX reserves are on track to hit the $1.5 trillion mark in the
second quarter of 2008, and might hit $2 trillion by the end of 2010.
Last month,
China
tapped into its reserves, importing a record 13.2 tons of crude oil,
up 24% from a year earlier, and not including 3 million barrels of
Russian crude that was pumped into storage tanks south of
Shanghai
.
After
the Bush economic team departs,
China
might find a tougher
US
president or a Democratic Congress, that aims to reverse the massive
transfer of wealth from the
US
to
China
, but could steer
Beijing
away from the US dollar. However, such a scenario is at least 2-years
away, and no change is expected in the gentleman’s agreement between
the US Treasury and the People’s Bank of China until then.
Japan
Targets US dollar for Nikkei Exporters
Japanese
investors have $14 trillion in savings, and earn more from interest
and dividends on investments held overseas, than from foreign trade.
Japan’s current account surplus rose 22.2% in August from a year
earlier to 1.48 trillion yen ($12.3 billion) earning 1.16 trillion yen
from overseas investments, dwarfing a trade surplus 312.4 billion yen.
Japanese investors were net buyers of 16 trillion yen ($140 billion)
of foreign bonds in 2005, but avoided the US Treasury market.
The
Bank of Japan affixed its reputation as the world’s second leading
interventionist bank, when it sold 35 trillion yen in exchange for
$315 billion US dollars, mostly between 105-yen and 112-yen, in late
2003 thru March 2004. The BoJ plowed the US dollars into US Treasuries
until August 2004, when its holdings peaked at a record high of $699.4
billion. Thus,
Tokyo
is the world’s biggest “yen carry” trader.
Tokyo
skillfully unwound $50 billion of its
“yen carry” trade over the past two years, without disturbing the
US dollar’s uptrend to 120-yen.
Tokyo
depends on the US dollar’s 5% interest rate advantage over Japanese
Libor rates, to enable the dollar to bounce back from periodic sales
of US Treasuries. Still,
Tokyo
holds onto the bulk of its US Treasuries, to maintain cordial
relations with its military protector, especially while under nuclear
threat from
North Korea
’s Kim Jong-il.
Japan’s
ministry of finance and the US Treasury might have a secret target
zone for the dollar /yen, and when the US$ approached 120-yen on
October 23rd, Japan’s top financial diplomat, Hiroshi
Watanabe told reporters in New York, “I see no reason for a further
deterioration in the yen given the strength in the Japanese
economy.”
Arab
Oil producers Recycle Petro-dollars thru
London
The
Institute of International Finance, an umbrella group for 340 of the
world’s private-sector banks, predicted in August that high oil
prices would lift the current account surpluses of six Gulf Arab
states to $230 billion this year, or 30% of their gross domestic
product. The bulk of the surpluses in
Saudi Arabia
, the
United Arab Emirates
,
Kuwait
,
Oman
,
Qatar
and
Bahrain
, are re-cycled into their already large private and official foreign
assets, such as in British gilts and US Treasuries.
The
six Gulf countries, all with currencies pegged to the dollar, are
working towards monetary union by 2010, but will initially peg their
future common currency to the US dollar. “It
makes sense for the
Gulf States
to peg its currencies to the dollar since the oil market is priced in
dollars,” said Sheikh Ahmed bin Mohammed Al Khalifa, the Bahraini
Minister of Finance on October 19th.

Amid
soaring oil prices, holdings of US Treasuries through
London
based brokers quadrupled in just fourteen months to a record $210.4
billion in August ’06, probably on behalf of Middle Eastern
investors. Only the UAE’s central bank has signaled a desire to
convert 10% of its largely dollar-denominated foreign exchange
reserves into Euros and gold, but is waiting for a dip in the Euro
before making the switch.
Shifting
Fortunes, Brazil is a buyer of US Bonds
The
four year boom in commodities prices to 25-year highs has been a
bonanza for
Brazil
’s economy, the largest in
Latin America
.
Brazil
’s exports reached $76.9 billion thru the first seven months
of this year, an increase of 14.7% from the same period in 2005,
netting a trade surplus of US$25.82 billion. The Bank of Brazil has
been a daily buyer of US$’s from exporters, who desire the higher
yielding Brazilian real.

Brazilian
central bank’s FX reserves have jumped by $20 billion to $72.3
billion this year. Brazilian-based traders added $11.5 billion of US
Treasuries in August, boosting their holdings to $43.2 billion, making
the country the 11th largest holder of
US
debt.
Brazil
’s finance ministry does not want to see the US dollar fall below
the psychological 2.0 real level, which could badly hurt its
exporters, especially in light of the recent drop in commodity prices.
But
the strong Brazilian real has also exerted downward pressure on the
benchmark IPCA consumer inflation index, which the central bank uses
as a guide to set interest rates. Consumer inflation rose 3.7% in the
12-months through September, the slowest pace since a 3.32% rise in
the year through June 1999. Inflation is below the central banks
target of 4.5% for 2006.

On
October 19th, Brazil’s bank’s nine-member monetary
policy committee, led by its President Henrique Meirelles, voted
unanimously to cut the so-called Selic rate, to 13.75% from 14.25%,
extending the longest period of monetary easing in the country’s
history. Borrowing
costs have fallen by 6% from 19.75% in September 2005, partly in a bid
to prevent the US dollar from falling under 2 Reals.
Still,
currency traders are likely to favor the Brazilian currency, which
carries a positive rate of return of 10%, adjusted for inflation. That
in turn, forces the Brazilian central bank to continue its daily
intervention on behalf of the
US
$, and rolling-over the proceeds into US Treasury bonds. Banco de
Brazil might choose to cut its Selic rate further at its next meeting
on November 29th
Russia
is an Outspoken Bear on the US dollar
Record
oil prices combined with record Russian oil exports, have boosted the
Kremlin’s foreign exchange reserves to a record $267 billion this
year, outstripped only by those of
China
and
Japan
. In August,
Russia
paid back $22.5 billion debt to the Paris Club of creditor nations,
and with its foreign debt standing at just $108 billion, S&P
raised
Moscow
’s foreign bond rating to BBB+.
It
represents a spectacular transformation from the financial meltdown in
1998 when
Russia
defaulted on its debt and the rouble crashed.
Booming crude oil, base metal and other commodity prices lifted
Russia
’s foreign trade surplus to $86.2 billion in the first half of 2006
from $66.3 billion in the same period a year ago.
With
its reserves swelling from petrodollar inflows, strong current account
surplus and booming economy, Russian kingpin Vladimir Putin ordered
the full convertibility of the rouble in July, and launched trading of
Russian oil, refined products and commodities on local bourses in
roubles.
Russia
was accumulating $10 billion of foreign exchange a month until July,
and the central bank bought more than $100
billion from the currency markets this year to slow the appreciation
of the rouble.

But
Moscow
remains a vocal bear on the US dollar, bucking the strategy of other
central banks in
China
,
Japan
, or
Brazil
. Instead,
Moscow
has steadily reduced its dollar holdings from three years ago. Sergei
Ignatyev, the central bank chief, said that about half of bank’s
reserves were held in US dollars, with the bulk of the rest in Euros.
He indicated the yen would be increased as a proportion of the total
reserves, and
Russia
would build positions in the Australian and Canadian dollars.
Federal
Reserve Underpins US$ with high fed funds rate
In
order to attract $3.5 billion each working day from Asia, Europe, and
the
Persian Gulf
, the Federal Reserve lifted the fed funds rate to 5.25% to discourage
dumping of the dollar. The fed funds rate is pegged 5% above
Japan
’s overnight loan rate, 2% above the ECB’s repo rate, and a
half-percent above the Bank of England’s base rate, even at the risk
of sinking the
US
housing market.
Russian
finance minister Alexei Kudrin dropped a bombshell on the dollar in
April 2006, wiping out half of it’s gain from the previous year.
“The US dollar is not the world’s absolute reserve currency. The
unsustainable
US
trade deficit is causing concern, and the international community can
hardly be satisfied with this instability,” he declared to members
of the IMF in
Washington
.

Kudrin’s
remarks touched off a mini-free fall for the US dollar index to the
84-level, in Q’2, forcing the Fed to hike the fed funds rate by
another half-percent to 5.25% in June, to stabilize the dollar. The
Russian central bank vexed the Fed for a second time on October 18th,
when it vocalized its intention to convert US$ into yen. The Federal
Reserve understands that it cannot afford to ease its grip on interest
rates in the fourth quarter, without triggering a speculative attack
against the US dollar.
On
October 4th, Federal Reserve Vice Chairman Donald Kohn
challenged expectations that Fed rate cuts will occur anytime soon.
“I am surprised at how little market participants seem to share my
sense that the uncertainties around inflation and their implications
for the stance of policy are fairly sizeable at this point,” he
warned.
Philly
Fed chief Charles Plosser was more hawkish, “The housing sector is
going through a painful, but necessary adjustment. But the expansion
is still on firm footing and growth is likely to accelerate in 2007.
We need to remain vigilant and maintain the current policy, or even
firming further, in the best interests of the economy’s long-run
performance. The predominant risks facing the economy now are on the
inflation side,” he warned on October 6th, ruling out Fed
rate cuts in Q’4.
But
at some point however, the Fed may have to confront the unenviable
task of defending the US dollar or US home prices. Now that the fed
funds rate has settled at 5.25%, US dollars bears such as the Russian
central bank, are acting before the earliest clue that the Fed is
about to lower the fed funds rate.
“Tricky”
Trichet makes US dollar look less Ugly
The
European Central Bank raised interest rates for a fifth time on
October 5th, to 3.25%, the highest level in almost four
years, and telegraphed another hike in December to 3.50% to combat
inflationary pressures. ECB chief Jean “Tricky” Trichet avoided
any clear message on where rate moves are headed after that, but said,
“Our monetary policy remains accommodative. If our baseline
scenarios are confirmed it will remain warranted to further withdraw
monetary accommodation.”
The
Euro M3 money supply and loan growth accelerated in August, driven by
a surge in new loans for corporate mergers and takeovers. The 12%
annual increase in business lending was the highest since September
2000. The M3 money supply measure jumped 0.4% to an annualized growth
rate of 8.2%, far above the central bank’s long discarded 4.50%
target rate.

But
“Tricky” Trichet’s rate hikes are deceiving, because they are
pegged far below the Euro zone’s producer inflation rate. Negative
interest rates have spawned European mergers and takeovers to the tune
of $1.2 trillion in the first eight months of 2006. The ECB can’t
control the M3 money supply, when borrowing is expanding at such a
rapid clip, and negative interest rates in
Europe
, enable the ECB to covertly make the US dollar look less ugly in the
foreign exchange market.
Bank
of
Japan
working behind the Scenes
Tokyo
has a lot of experience in battling
foreign currency speculators, when the dollar sinks against the
Japanese yen, and threatening the best interests of Nikkei-225
exporters. Yet the BoJ appeared to be facing a mission impossible,
trying to dismantle its five year super easy money policy on one hand,
without crushing the US dollar against the Japanese yen with the other
hand.

The
Bank of Japan has withdrawn 27 trillion yen from the banking system
since March 9th, and lifted its overnight loan rate above
zero percent on July 14th. Previously, the BoJ was flooding
its banking system with an excess of 26 trillion yen above the reserve
requirements of local banks, which often submerged the six-month Yen
Libor rate below zero percent from 2003 through 2005.
The
US dollar did go into a mini meltdown against the yen in late April
thru early may, plunging 10-yen to as low as 109-yen, as the BoJ moved
aggressively to drain excess yen out of the banking system. But
Tokyo
’s financial warlords went into action when the dollar fell towards
110-yen, with a predictable barrage of jawboning, peppered with
threats of outright intervention in the currency market.
Tokyo
received valuable outside help from the
Federal Reserve, which hiked the fed funds rate on two occasions to
5.25% since March 9th.
Tokyo
then rigged the components in its consumer price index on August 25th,
handcuffing the BoJ from further rate hikes in the fourth quarter.
That was the icing on the cake, which enabled
Tokyo
to restore the dollar to its previous position of 118 to 120-yen.
The
Bank of
England
’s Radical Monetary policy
The
Bank of England has tried to cap the British pound at $1.90, by
keeping its base rate exactly where it was at the start of 2005. The
BoE also tolerates an explosion of the British money supply that is
more characteristic of emerging economies in
China
and
India
. The
UK
’s M4 money supply surged to a 14.5% annualized growth rate in
September, its fastest rate in 16-years, setting-off alarm bells in
London
.
But
time seems to be running out for the BoE’s ultra easy money policy.
The
UK
economy grew by 0.7% in the July-September period, lifting the annual
rate of expansion to 2.8%, the fastest pace since the third quarter of
2004. That seems to cement the case for a quarter-point BOE rate hike
to 5.00% on November 9th. BoE chief Mervyn King warned on
October 10th, “That decision will be taken only in
November, and much can change between now and then.”

From
1997 through 2003, the Bank of England closely monitored its benchmark
M4 money supply, adjusting its base rate higher to counter strong M4
growth, and lowered rates when the money supply slowed. However, the
BoE abandoned the discipline of monetarism over the past two years,
and has lost control of the money supply, which now threatens the
UK
economy with an inflationary surge.
British
interest rates are far too low to curb borrowing or the velocity of
the money supply. Net
mortgage lending rose by 6.2 billion pounds in August, up from the
monthly average rise of 5.4 billion over the previous six months, and
beating the last record set in April 2004, when it increased by 6
billion pounds. Asking prices for
UK
homes in the four weeks through October 7th rose to 338,000
pounds, or 11.5% higher from a year earlier, the biggest annual gain
in two years
The
BoE’s Andrew Sentance said inflation could slip in the short term
because of lower energy prices, but rising wages present a problem.
“In terms of inflation, there is the risk if we have continuing
inflation above target that it does begin to feed into wage increases.
That’s a significant worry,” said Sentance.
UK
wages including bonuses grew an annual 4.4% in the quarter through
July.
Quizzed
on the importance of M4’s 14.5% expansion, “The recent growth in
M4 could ultimately have an impact on the economy. I view this as an
issue of concern about the future path of inflation,” said BOE
member Timothy Besley. Sentance said the 14.5% M4 growth rate, the
fastest since 1990, was an “amber light”.
The
New Zealand dollar offers Interesting Insights
It
would be far fetched to put the
New Zealand
dollar, (kiwi) in the same league as the world’s top-4 reserve
currencies. Still, currency traders are often attracted to its high
yield, but lose sleep over its huge external deficits. The kiwi has
been on a rollercoaster ride in 2006, amid shifting expectations over
the direction of NZ Libor rates and the ability of the NZ economy to
sustain high interest rates.
The
Kiwi is buoyed by the Reserve Bank of
New Zealand
’s (RBNZ) 7.25% cash rate, which is 2% above the
US
fed funds rate and 7% higher than the Bank of Japan’s overnight loan
rate. But the NZ current account deficit widened to NZ$15.2 billion
($US10 billion) in the year ended June 30th, equivalent to
9.7% of gross domestic product. The compares to South Africa’s 6.4%
c/a to GDP ratio of 6.4%, which encouraged traders to hammer the South
African rand by 25% this year..

Ten
months ago, the kiwi began a 20% devaluation against the Japanese yen,
on news that NZ’s economy had ground to a halt in the third quarter
of 2005. On January 26th, the RBNZ halted its two year rate
hike campaign at 7.25%, and while it reiterated that it saw no scope
for an easing, it added, “We do not expect to raise the official
cash rate further in this cycle. However, this possibility cannot be
ruled out until we see clear evidence of a sustained weakening in
domestic demand.”
Anticipating
a peak in NZ Libor rate and an RBNZ easing cycle in 2007, Japanese
traders rushed to unwind the “yen carry” trade. The Bank of Japan
started to dismantle its ultra-easy money policy, ultimately draining
27 trillion yen out of the
Tokyo
money markets. Japanese investors, who had bought NZ$12 billion of NZ
bonds in 2005, started dumping the kiwi, after NZ Prime minister Helen
Clark applauded the kiwi’s devaluation.
Yet
the kiwi stabilized at 70-yen in the summer of 2006, when traders
began to have second thoughts about the inevitability of RBNZ rate
cuts this year. Last month, RBNZ chief Alan Bollard insisted that he
wouldn’t cut rates for “some considerable time because inflation
hasn’t abated”. Consumer prices rose 4% in the year ended June 30th,
above the central bank’s 1 to 3% target. Kiwi Libor rates climbed to
7.62% last week, discounting an RBNZ rate hike to 7.50% on October 26th.
Japanese
traders are once again, playing the “yen carry” in the both the NZ
kiwi and the US dollar. Interest rate differentials are a powerful
draw in the foreign exchange markets, even for currencies with
chronically high external trade deficits.
“The
world economy is doing miraculously well,” said former Fed chief
Paul Volcker on October 17th, because “there are some big
imbalances underneath all of this, especially the flow of capital into
the
US
. If the music stopped or slowed down a bit in terms of the foreign
money coming into the
US
, you’ve got a potential problem for the US dollar and inflation,”
Volcker warned.
Back
to Dollar Hegemony
|